Coins & Bullion: A Practical Guide for IDC Buyers
Learn what a customer has, what gives it value, and the next step to take.
Two reasons a coin can be valuable
1. The metal inside it. Gold, silver, platinum or palladium can give an item value even when it is common. Products bought mainly for their precious metal are called bullion. Bullion can be a coin, a privately made round or a bar.
2. Collectors want that exact item. Date, mintmark, rarity, condition and authenticity can make a coin worth more than its metal. This is called collector or numismatic value. Some valuable coins contain no precious metal at all.
Your job at the counter: identify the item, verify what it contains, and get the correct bid. You do not need to guess a rare coin’s grade or value—Clearwater can help.
Learn the words you’ll see on this page
- Face value
- The denomination printed on a coin. A $1 Silver Eagle is not valued like a $1 bill.
- Spot price
- A market reference price for one troy ounce of a precious metal. It is not automatically the price IDC pays or charges.
- Troy ounce
- The precious-metals weight unit: about 31.1035 grams. An ordinary household ounce is about 28.35 grams.
- Fineness / purity
- How much of an item is precious metal: .999 means 99.9%; .900 means 90%. The rest is other metal.
- Fine-metal weight / ASW / AGW
- The actual amount of silver or gold inside an item, excluding other metals. ASW means actual silver weight; AGW means actual gold weight.
- Melt value
- Fine-metal weight multiplied by spot price. A reference value before buying costs or collector premiums.
- Premium
- The amount above metal value. It depends on the exact product and market demand; a customer’s premium paid is not necessarily recoverable.
- Clad
- Layers of different metals. Most modern circulation dimes and quarters are copper-nickel clad with no silver. Some special silver-clad issues do contain silver.
- Proof / uncirculated
- Proof describes a special method of manufacture, often with mirror-like surfaces. Uncirculated describes a coin without circulation wear. Neither word guarantees precious metal or rarity.
- Mintmark
- A small letter identifying the mint that made a coin: for example D, S or CC. Its meaning depends on the date and coin type.
- Round / coin / bar
- A coin is issued by a government with a monetary denomination. A round is a coin-shaped private product. A bar is a cast or struck metal product. Authenticate all three.
- Slab / certified coin
- A coin sealed in a grading-service holder. The label describes an opinion of identity and condition; the coin and holder still require authentication.
Metal-value check
No offer percentage is assumed. Obtain the current IDC buy schedule and any required Clearwater approval. Inputs clear on reload.
Key date: a major scarce issue in its series. Semi-key: a scarcer secondary date. Better date: worth checking separately; any premium depends on condition and market demand.
Date notation: a bare year generally means Philadelphia with no mintmark for the classic series here; D = Denver, S = San Francisco, O = New Orleans, CC = Carson City, W = West Point. Obverse = front; reverse = back. A 1916 Barber dime is not the 1916-D Mercury dime key. Open each coin’s date guide below. These are selected staff screening lists, not exhaustive or universal rarity rankings. Varieties and special finishes are labeled separately. An unlisted date can still be valuable. Set aside flagged coins for Clearwater; never assume a rare-coin premium from the year alone.
39 reference entries
Pennies / Cents
Indian Head cent
Liberty wearing feathered headdress, 1859–1909. Base metal, no silver.
Key dates, semi-keys & better dates
- Key dates / priority rarities
- 1877, 1909-S.
- Semi-keys / next checks
- 1864-L, 1869, 1870, 1871, 1872, 1908-S.
- Better dates / collector issues
- 1866, 1867, 1868, 1873, 1878.
- Varieties & identification
- 1873 Doubled LIBERTY; 1888/7 overdate; 1864 bronze with L on ribbon.
All are base metal. 1864 has multiple compositions and varieties; counterfeit keys and altered dates exist.
Series reference ↗Next step: Check the series date guide below; set aside flagged dates and varieties for Clearwater review.
Lincoln cent • Wheat and modern
Lincoln portrait, 1909 onward; Wheat reverse through 1958. Base metal, no silver.
Key dates, semi-keys & better dates
- Key dates / priority rarities
- 1909-S VDB, 1914-D, 1931-S.
- Semi-keys / next checks
- 1909-S (without VDB), 1911-S, 1912-S, 1913-S, 1914-S, 1915-S, 1924-D, 1926-S.
- Better dates / collector issues
- 1910-S, 1922-D (normal D), 1923-S; earlier S-mint cents in higher grades.
- Varieties & identification
- 1922 No D strong reverse; 1955, 1969-S and 1972 doubled dies; 1990 No-S PROOF; 1992 Close AM; 1998–2000 Wide AM circulation varieties.
1943 bronze and 1944 steel are rare off-metal claims: authenticate. Ordinary 1943 steel cents are common. Doubling and missing mintmarks alone prove nothing.
Series reference ↗Next step: Check the series date guide below; set aside flagged dates and varieties for Clearwater review.
Nickels
Liberty V nickel
Liberty portrait / large Roman numeral V, 1883–1912 normal issues. Copper-nickel, no silver.
Key dates, semi-keys & better dates
- Key dates / priority rarities
- 1885, 1886, 1912-S.
- Semi-keys / next checks
- 1888, 1894.
- Better dates / collector issues
- 1883 With CENTS, 1912-D.
- Varieties & identification
- 1883 No CENTS is commonly gold-plated as a “racketeer” nickel; plating does not make it gold bullion.
A purported 1913 Liberty nickel is an exceptional-rarity claim—immediate Clearwater authentication.
Series reference ↗Next step: Check the series date guide below; set aside flagged dates and varieties for Clearwater review.
Buffalo nickel
Native American portrait / bison, 1913–1938. Copper-nickel, no silver.
Key dates, semi-keys & better dates
- Key dates / priority rarities
- 1913-S Type 2, 1926-S.
- Semi-keys / next checks
- 1913-D Type 2, 1921-S, 1924-S.
- Better dates / collector issues
- 1914-D, 1915-S, 1917-S, 1918-D, 1918-S, 1919-D, 1919-S, 1920-D, 1923-S, 1925-S.
- Varieties & identification
- 1916 doubled-die obverse; 1918/7-D; 1937-D Three-Legged.
Type 2 has FIVE CENTS in a recessed area. Do not acid-restore dates; fake Three-Legged coins can be made by removing a leg.
Series reference ↗Next step: Check the series date guide below; set aside flagged dates and varieties for Clearwater review.
Jefferson nickel • regular alloy
Jefferson portrait, 1938 onward; normal alloy is copper-nickel. Silver wartime issues are separate.
Key dates, semi-keys & better dates
- Key dates / priority rarities
- 1939-D, 1950-D are traditional date-set keys, not major rarities in every grade.
- Semi-keys / next checks
- 1938-D, 1938-S, 1939-S.
- Better dates / collector issues
- 1951-S, 1955; exceptional Full Steps coins of many dates need review.
- Varieties & identification
- 1939 doubled MONTICELLO; 1942-D/D; 1954-S/D, 1955-D/S; 1971 No-S PROOF.
1950-D was heavily saved: low mintage alone does not guarantee a large premium. Silver war nickels have their own card.
Series reference ↗Next step: Check the series date guide below; set aside flagged dates and varieties for Clearwater review.
War nickel • large P / D / S above Monticello
1942–1945 with LARGE mintmark above dome: 35% silver, 5.00 g.
Key dates, semi-keys & better dates
- Key dates / priority rarities
- No major ordinary circulated date key within the silver-war-nickel subset.
- Semi-keys / next checks
- 1943-D is a lower-mintage issue; not an automatic premium over the silver bid.
- Better dates / collector issues
- All dates can be worth more in exceptional uncirculated condition with qualifying Full Steps.
- Varieties & identification
- 1943-P 3-over-2 overdate and doubled-die reverse; 1945-P doubled-die reverse.
Large mintmark above Monticello confirms the normal silver type. Full Steps describes sharp uninterrupted steps, not silver content.
Series reference ↗Next step: Confirm reverse mintmark before placing in silver bin.
Dimes
Barber dime
Liberty wearing a cap and wreath, 1892–1916; 90% silver.
Key dates, semi-keys & better dates
- Key dates / priority rarities
- 1895-O. Exceptional rarity: 1894-S—immediate expert authentication.
- Semi-keys / next checks
- 1892-S, 1893-O, 1895, 1896-O, 1896-S, 1897-O.
- Better dates / collector issues
- 1894-O, 1901-S, 1903-S, 1904-S, 1913-S.
- Varieties & identification
- Check mintmark below the wreath on the reverse.
Selected dates only; original higher-grade Barber dimes of any date deserve review.
Series reference ↗Next step: Check the series date guide below; set aside flagged dates and varieties for Clearwater review.
Mercury dime
Winged Liberty head, 1916–1945; 90% silver. Often called a Mercury dime.
Key dates, semi-keys & better dates
- Key dates / priority rarities
- 1916-D.
- Semi-keys / next checks
- 1921, 1921-D, 1926-S.
- Better dates / collector issues
- 1919-D, 1919-S, 1924-S, 1925-D, 1925-S, 1927-D, 1931-D.
- Varieties & identification
- 1942/1 and 1942/1-D overdates. Mintmark is on reverse, left of the fasces base.
Added D mintmarks are a known problem on 1916 coins. Full Bands is an expert strike assessment, not a date.
Series reference ↗Next step: Check the series date guide below; set aside flagged dates and varieties for Clearwater review.
Roosevelt dime
Roosevelt portrait; 1946–1964 regular issues are 90% silver. 1965+ regular circulation issues are clad.
Key dates, semi-keys & better dates
- Key dates / priority rarities
- No major rarity by ordinary circulated silver date alone.
- Semi-keys / next checks
- 1949-S, 1955, 1955-D, 1955-S—scarcer silver issues; premium depends on condition.
- Better dates / collector issues
- 1949, 1949-D, 1950-S; 1996-W is a clad collector issue, not a silver dime.
- Varieties & identification
- 1968, 1970, 1975 and 1983 No-S PROOF dimes; 1982 no-mintmark circulation variety.
Ordinary Philadelphia dimes before 1980 normally lack a mintmark. That does not make them rare No-S proofs.
Series reference ↗Next step: Check the series date guide below; set aside flagged dates and varieties for Clearwater review.
Quarters
Barber quarter
Liberty wearing a cap and wreath, 1892–1916; 90% silver.
Key dates, semi-keys & better dates
- Key dates / priority rarities
- 1896-S, 1901-S, 1913-S.
- Semi-keys / next checks
- 1896-O, 1897-S, 1901-O, 1909-O, 1914-S.
- Better dates / collector issues
- 1892-S, 1893-S, 1894-O, 1895-S, 1898-S, 1907-S, 1911-S, 1912-S.
- Varieties & identification
- Mintmark below the eagle on reverse. Authentication is essential on the three keys.
Many dates become scarce in Very Fine or better. Do not bulk-price attractive original examples without review.
Series reference ↗Next step: Check the series date guide below; set aside flagged dates and varieties for Clearwater review.
Standing Liberty quarter
Standing Liberty figure, 1916–1930; 90% silver.
Key dates, semi-keys & better dates
- Key dates / priority rarities
- 1916; major variety: 1918/7-S.
- Semi-keys / next checks
- 1921, 1923-S, 1927-S (especially higher grades).
- Better dates / collector issues
- 1919-D, 1919-S, 1920-D, 1920-S, 1924-D, 1926-S, 1927-D.
- Varieties & identification
- 1917 Type 1 / Type 2; mintmark by the date at left. Full Head needs expert assessment.
Do not infer a 1916 from a missing date. Dateless and altered-date pieces need expert identification.
Series reference ↗Next step: Check the series date guide below; set aside flagged dates and varieties for Clearwater review.
Washington quarter • silver era
Washington portrait, 1932–1964 regular issues; 90% silver.
Key dates, semi-keys & better dates
- Key dates / priority rarities
- 1932-D, 1932-S.
- Semi-keys / next checks
- 1936-D, 1937-S.
- Better dates / collector issues
- 1934-D, 1935-D, 1935-S, 1936-S, 1938-S, 1939-S, 1940-D.
- Varieties & identification
- 1934 and 1937 doubled-die obverses; 1942-D doubled-die obverse; 1950-D/S and 1950-S/D mintmark varieties.
Premiums for better dates can depend heavily on grade. Silver-era mintmarks are on the reverse below the eagle.
Series reference ↗Next step: Check the series date guide below; set aside flagged dates and varieties for Clearwater review.
Half Dollars
Barber half dollar
Liberty wearing a cap and wreath, 1892–1915; 90% silver.
Key dates, semi-keys & better dates
- Key dates / priority rarities
- No single universal key; prioritize 1904-S and the 1892-O Micro O variety.
- Semi-keys / next checks
- 1892-O, 1892-S, 1893-S, 1896-S, 1897-O, 1913, 1914, 1915.
- Better dates / collector issues
- 1896-O, 1897-S, 1901-S, 1907-S, 1910, 1911-S.
- Varieties & identification
- 1892-O Micro O needs specialist attribution; do not assume every 1892-O is Micro O.
Scarcity changes sharply with grade; attractive Barber halves deserve review even when the date is absent here.
Series reference ↗Next step: Check the series date guide below; set aside flagged dates and varieties for Clearwater review.
Walking Liberty half dollar
Full-length Liberty walking, 1916–1947; 90% silver.
Key dates, semi-keys & better dates
- Key dates / priority rarities
- 1921, 1921-D; 1921-S becomes especially important in higher grades.
- Semi-keys / next checks
- 1916-S, 1917-D obverse mintmark, 1917-S obverse mintmark, 1919-D, 1919-S, 1938-D.
- Better dates / collector issues
- 1916, 1916-D, 1917-D reverse mintmark, 1917-S reverse mintmark, 1920-D, 1920-S, 1923-S.
- Varieties & identification
- 1916 mintmarks are on the front. In 1917 they occur on front or back; later mintmarks are on back.
Early dates and original coins grading Fine or better need closer review. 1941-S is chiefly a high-grade strike concern.
Series reference ↗Next step: Check the series date guide below; set aside flagged dates and varieties for Clearwater review.
Franklin half dollar
Benjamin Franklin / Liberty Bell, 1948–1963; 90% silver.
Key dates, semi-keys & better dates
- Key dates / priority rarities
- No major key by ordinary circulated date alone.
- Semi-keys / next checks
- 1949-S and 1955 are traditional better-date priorities.
- Better dates / collector issues
- 1948, 1948-D, 1949, 1949-D, 1950-D, 1951-S, 1952-S, 1953.
- Varieties & identification
- 1953-S with genuine Full Bell Lines is a major strike rarity; 1955 Bugs Bunny variety.
1953-S without Full Bell Lines is not the same rarity. FBL means complete qualifying lines on the Liberty Bell and requires expert grading.
Series reference ↗Next step: Check the series date guide below; set aside flagged dates and varieties for Clearwater review.
Kennedy half • 1964
1964 Kennedy half: 90% silver; nominal 12.50 g.
Key dates, semi-keys & better dates
- Key dates / priority rarities
- 1970-D is a traditional circulation-strike set key; 1998-S matte-finish silver is a special collector issue.
- Semi-keys / next checks
- 1987-P and 1987-D were issued for collector sets.
- Better dates / collector issues
- 1964 Accented Hair PROOF; 2014-W gold and 2014 silver anniversary issues require exact product identification.
- Varieties & identification
- 1964-D doubled/quadrupled dies; 1966 SMS doubled die; 1974-D doubled die; 1979-S and 1981-S Type 2 proofs.
1964 itself is common. Proof, SMS, matte and regular strikes must be distinguished; never transfer a premium between them.
Series reference ↗Next step: Separate from 40% and clad halves.
Kennedy half • 1965–1970
40% silver; nominal 11.50 g. Includes 1970-D collector issue.
Key dates, semi-keys & better dates
- Key dates / priority rarities
- 1970-D is a traditional circulation-strike set key; 1998-S matte-finish silver is a special collector issue.
- Semi-keys / next checks
- 1987-P and 1987-D were issued for collector sets.
- Better dates / collector issues
- 1964 Accented Hair PROOF; 2014-W gold and 2014 silver anniversary issues require exact product identification.
- Varieties & identification
- 1964-D doubled/quadrupled dies; 1966 SMS doubled die; 1974-D doubled die; 1979-S and 1981-S Type 2 proofs.
1964 itself is common. Proof, SMS, matte and regular strikes must be distinguished; never transfer a premium between them.
Series reference ↗Next step: Use 40% buy schedule; review better collector pieces.
Kennedy half • 1971+ regular clad
Regular circulation composition is copper-nickel clad; nominal 11.34 g.
Key dates, semi-keys & better dates
- Key dates / priority rarities
- 1970-D is a traditional circulation-strike set key; 1998-S matte-finish silver is a special collector issue.
- Semi-keys / next checks
- 1987-P and 1987-D were issued for collector sets.
- Better dates / collector issues
- 1964 Accented Hair PROOF; 2014-W gold and 2014 silver anniversary issues require exact product identification.
- Varieties & identification
- 1964-D doubled/quadrupled dies; 1966 SMS doubled die; 1974-D doubled die; 1979-S and 1981-S Type 2 proofs.
1964 itself is common. Proof, SMS, matte and regular strikes must be distinguished; never transfer a premium between them.
Series reference ↗Next step: Identify exact issue; proof finish alone means no silver guarantee.
Dollars
Morgan silver dollar
Liberty in a cap / eagle, 1878–1904 and 1921; 90% silver, nominal 26.73 g.
Key dates, semi-keys & better dates
- Key dates / priority rarities
- 1889-CC, 1893-S, 1894 (Philadelphia). 1895 Philadelphia is a famous PROOF-only collectible issue.
- Semi-keys / next checks
- 1879-CC, 1893, 1893-CC, 1893-O, 1895-O, 1895-S.
- Better dates / collector issues
- 1878-CC, 1880-CC, 1885-CC, 1890-CC, 1891-CC, 1892-CC, 1899 (Philadelphia), 1903-O, 1904-S; review ALL CC coins.
- Varieties & identification
- 1878 reverse/tail-feather varieties; 1884-S, 1892-S, 1896-O and 1901 are particularly grade-sensitive.
No mintmark means Philadelphia for these dollars. 1895-O/S are different from the 1895 Philadelphia proof. Added mintmarks and altered dates require authentication.
Series reference ↗Next step: Check the series date guide below; set aside flagged dates and varieties for Clearwater review.
Peace silver dollar
Liberty with radiate crown / perched eagle, 1921–1928 and 1934–1935; 90% silver, nominal 26.73 g.
Key dates, semi-keys & better dates
- Key dates / priority rarities
- 1921 High Relief, 1928 (Philadelphia).
- Semi-keys / next checks
- 1934-S—especially scarce uncirculated; 1927, 1927-D, 1927-S.
- Better dates / collector issues
- 1924-S, 1925-S, 1928-S, 1934, 1934-D, 1935, 1935-S.
- Varieties & identification
- 1934-D doubled-die obverse; 1935-S three-ray reverse variety.
1928-S is not the 1928 Philadelphia key. Worn 1934-S coins are much more available than uncirculated examples.
Series reference ↗Next step: Check the series date guide below; set aside flagged dates and varieties for Clearwater review.
Eisenhower dollar • verified silver
Selected 1971–1974-S and 1976-S collector issues are 40% silver; nominal 24.59 g.
Key dates, semi-keys & better dates
- Key dates / priority rarities
- 1972 Philadelphia Type 2 reverse is the principal variety to flag.
- Semi-keys / next checks
- 1973 and 1973-D clad collector-set issues.
- Better dates / collector issues
- 1971-S and 1972-S silver uncirculated coins in exceptional condition; 1976 Type 1 / Type 2 clad reverses.
- Varieties & identification
- 1972 Type 2: Earth has weak/indistinct islands below Florida. Do not confuse this with 1976 Type 2 lettering.
Most circulated Ikes are common. A 1972-D is not the 1972 Philadelphia Type 2 variety; S-mint coins can be silver or clad.
Series reference ↗Next step: Verify exact variety and composition before quoting.
Eisenhower dollar • clad
Most Ikes are clad; nominal 22.68 g. Large dollar does not mean silver.
Key dates, semi-keys & better dates
- Key dates / priority rarities
- 1972 Philadelphia Type 2 reverse is the principal variety to flag.
- Semi-keys / next checks
- 1973 and 1973-D clad collector-set issues.
- Better dates / collector issues
- 1971-S and 1972-S silver uncirculated coins in exceptional condition; 1976 Type 1 / Type 2 clad reverses.
- Varieties & identification
- 1972 Type 2: Earth has weak/indistinct islands below Florida. Do not confuse this with 1976 Type 2 lettering.
Most circulated Ikes are common. A 1972-D is not the 1972 Philadelphia Type 2 variety; S-mint coins can be silver or clad.
Series reference ↗Next step: Separate from silver Ikes; follow approved collector buy list.
Susan B. Anthony dollar
Susan B. Anthony portrait, 1979–1981 and 1999. Copper-nickel clad, no silver.
Key dates, semi-keys & better dates
- Key dates / priority rarities
- No major rarity by ordinary date alone.
- Semi-keys / next checks
- 1981-P, 1981-D, 1981-S circulation strikes were collector-set issues.
- Better dates / collector issues
- 1979-P Wide Rim / Near Date.
- Varieties & identification
- 1979-S and 1981-S Type 2 PROOF mintmarks.
1979-P Wide Rim is a specific variety. Most 1979 dollars are common; no silver in standard issues.
Series reference ↗Next step: Check the series date guide below; set aside flagged dates and varieties for Clearwater review.
Sacagawea / Native American dollar
Sacagawea carrying a child, 2000 onward. Gold-colored base metal, no gold or silver.
Key dates, semi-keys & better dates
- Key dates / priority rarities
- No major ordinary circulation-date key.
- Semi-keys / next checks
- 2000-P Cheerios prototype reverse is a major VARIETY; not every 2000-P qualifies.
- Better dates / collector issues
- 2000-P Goodacre presentation pieces; special enhanced-finish collector issues.
- Varieties & identification
- 2000-P Wounded Eagle die gouges; missing edge lettering on applicable later issues.
Cheerios requires the correct detailed tail-feather reverse. Gold color is not gold. Unusual mule/error claims go to Clearwater.
Series reference ↗Next step: Check the series date guide below; set aside flagged dates and varieties for Clearwater review.
Presidential dollar
Presidential portrait / Statue of Liberty. Gold-colored base metal, no gold or silver.
Key dates, semi-keys & better dates
- Key dates / priority rarities
- No major rarity by ordinary date alone.
- Semi-keys / next checks
- No universal semi-key list; identify president, year, mintmark and finish.
- Better dates / collector issues
- 2015-P/D Truman, Eisenhower, Kennedy and Johnson are lower-mintage collector issues; premiums require a current bid.
- Varieties & identification
- 2007 Washington / Adams missing-edge-lettering errors; doubled edge lettering on some issues.
Read the edge. Lettering facing up or down is normal on circulation strikes and is not an error.
Series reference ↗Next step: Check the series date guide below; set aside flagged dates and varieties for Clearwater review.
Bullion
American Silver Eagle • standard 1 oz
1986 onward; one troy ounce fine silver, $1 face value.
Key dates, semi-keys & better dates
- Key dates / priority rarities
- 1995-W PROOF; 2019-S ENHANCED REVERSE PROOF.
- Semi-keys / next checks
- 1996 bullion strike; 2008-W burnished Reverse of 2007 VARIETY.
- Better dates / collector issues
- 1994 bullion; 2006-P reverse proof, 2011-S uncirculated, 2011-P reverse proof, 2020-W V75 proof.
- Varieties & identification
- Exact finish, mintmark and product are essential. 2019-S standard proof is not the Enhanced Reverse Proof.
Bullion, burnished, proof and reverse proof are different products. Special labels alone do not establish rarity.
Series reference ↗Next step: Authenticate weight, dimensions and metal; review premium issues.
Silver rounds / bars
Read maker, fineness and stated TROY weight; verify authenticity.
Key dates, semi-keys & better dates
- Key dates / priority rarities
- Not applicable as one combined series.
- Semi-keys / next checks
- Not applicable as one combined series.
- Better dates / collector issues
- Vintage Engelhard, Johnson Matthey, poured bars, unusual sizes and identifiable scarce designs may carry collector premiums. Date alone is not a key-date system.
- Varieties & identification
- Send exact product photos and identifying marks to Clearwater.
Do not assume that an unlisted date or maker is common. All uncertain collector premiums require Clearwater review.
Series reference ↗Next step: Use custom calculator only after metal and weight are verified.
Gold Coins
American Gold Eagle • $50 / $25 / $10 / $5
Fine-gold contents: 1 / 0.5 / 0.25 / 0.1 troy oz respectively; alloy is 22 karat.
Key dates, semi-keys & better dates
- Key dates / priority rarities
- No single key applies to all four sizes and finishes.
- Semi-keys / next checks
- 1991 $10 quarter-ounce bullion is a recognized scarcer issue; do not apply that status to all 1991 sizes.
- Better dates / collector issues
- 2006-W burnished fractionals; 2008-W burnished fractionals; 2020-W $50 V75 proof are collector-review priorities.
- Varieties & identification
- 1999-W $5 and $10 struck with unfinished proof dies; 2006-W $50 reverse proof.
Review by denomination AND date AND finish. Ordinary bullion and W-mint collector issues do not share the same premium.
Series reference ↗Next step: Authenticate; use gold calculator with stated fine-gold ounces.
American Gold Buffalo • standard $50 1 oz
Standard one-ounce Buffalo contains 1 troy oz fine gold; .9999 fine.
Key dates, semi-keys & better dates
- Key dates / priority rarities
- Collector priority: 2008-W burnished issues, including the one-ounce coin and fractional sizes.
- Semi-keys / next checks
- 2008-W proof fractional $5, $10 and $25 issues.
- Better dates / collector issues
- 2013-W $50 reverse proof; other proof and burnished products require exact identification.
- Varieties & identification
- Do not confuse the ordinary 2008 bullion ounce, 2008-W proof ounce and 2008-W burnished ounce.
A Buffalo nickel is base metal; a Gold Buffalo is a separate modern gold product. This card is a product watchlist, not a universal price hierarchy.
Series reference ↗Next step: Authenticate before using approved gold bid.
Pre-1933 U.S. gold
Common $2.50 / $5 / $10 / $20: approximately .12094 / .24187 / .48375 / .96750 oz fine gold.
Key dates, semi-keys & better dates
- Key dates / priority rarities
- Examples: $2.50 Indian 1911-D; $5 Indian 1909-O and 1929; $10 Indian 1920-S and 1933; $20 Saint-Gaudens 1927-D.
- Semi-keys / next checks
- Examples: $2.50 Indian 1914, 1914-D; $5 Indian 1911-D, 1913-S; $10 Indian 1911-D, 1913-S.
- Better dates / collector issues
- All Carson City gold; 1907 High Relief $20; any early gold or unusual mintmark. These are selected review flags, not a complete date list.
- Varieties & identification
- Every Liberty/Indian denomination is a different series. $20 Liberty and $20 Saint-Gaudens do not share key-date lists.
ALL pre-1933 gold goes to Clearwater for date, grade and authenticity review. Do not rely on this short list to clear a purchase. A claimed 1933 $20 needs immediate specialist handling.
Series reference ↗Next step: Clearwater review before final offer; no destructive testing.
Sets
Bicentennial: silver or regular clad?
The drummer quarter, Independence Hall half dollar and Liberty Bell / moon dollar were made in both regular copper-nickel clad and special 40% silver versions. Start with the exact package, then verify the coins.
| What arrives at the counter | Original packaging clues | What it contains |
|---|---|---|
| 3-coin silver uncirculated set | Usually a red envelope with white lettering identifying a Bicentennial Silver Uncirculated Set. Three coins sealed together in a flexible plastic pack with white edging and a cardboard insert. | Quarter, half and dollar; all S-mint, all 40% silver. |
| Holiday silver uncirculated package | White / crimson gift envelope showing Independence Hall in a winter scene. This is a legitimate alternate Mint package. | The same three 40% silver uncirculated coins. |
| 3-coin silver proof set | Blue folding wallet-style case; red interior with patriotic striping, blue coin panel and three individual clear capsules. Look for the words identifying the Bicentennial Silver Proof Set. | Quarter, half and dollar; all S-mint, all 40% silver, with proof finish. |
| Regular 1975 or 1976 proof set | Six coins in the standard rigid Mint lens: cent, nickel, dime, Bicentennial quarter, half and dollar. | The Bicentennial coins are regular copper-nickel clad, even though they have S mintmarks. |
| Regular 1975 or 1976 uncirculated mint set | Multiple denominations in Philadelphia / Denver Mint packs, rather than the special three-coin silver product. | The Bicentennial coins are regular copper-nickel clad. |
| Loose coins / dealer-made holder | Albums, aftermarket cases, labels and boxes may contain substituted coins. | Unknown until each coin is identified and checked. |
For loose coins, use several checks
- Find the mintmark. Normal silver issues have an S. Ordinary no-mintmark and D issues are clad. An S alone does not prove silver: S-mint clad proofs also exist. An apparent exception goes to Clearwater.
- Examine the edge. Regular clad usually shows a distinct copper-colored center stripe. Silver-clad often looks more silver-gray, but its layered core can show color. Edge appearance alone is not conclusive.
- Compare nominal weights. Use the table below as a screening aid. The quarter and half differences are very small; wear, tolerances and scale accuracy matter.
- Confirm with an appropriate non-destructive metal test. Use IDC’s approved procedure or Clearwater. Never scratch a proof coin or remove it from Mint packaging simply to weigh it.
| Coin | 40% silver | Regular clad |
|---|---|---|
| Quarter | 5.75 g | 5.67 g |
| Kennedy half | 11.50 g | 11.34 g |
| Eisenhower dollar | 24.59 g | 22.68 g |
Counter rule: package wording and contents are clues—not authentication. Confirm every coin when the holder is opened, altered or unfamiliar. Rare off-metal errors require expert review.
Packaging references: U.S. Mint holiday packaging · Greysheet proof packaging · Uncirculated packaging
Bicentennial 3-coin SILVER set
1776–1976-S quarter, half and Ike; all three must be verified 40% silver.
Key dates, semi-keys & better dates
- Key dates / priority rarities
- No ordinary Bicentennial date is a key by date alone.
- Semi-keys / next checks
- No broadly recognized semi-key within a standard three-coin set.
- Better dates / collector issues
- High-grade, cameo and unusual varieties require specialist review.
- Varieties & identification
- 1976 dollar Type 1 / Type 2 applies to clad reverses; silver/clad identity comes before rarity claims.
1776–1976 on a coin does not itself make it rare or silver.
Series reference ↗Next step: Confirm all 3 coins; Clearwater reviews any collector premium.
Bicentennial regular clad coins / proof set
1776–1976 quarter, half and dollar also exist in copper-nickel clad.
Key dates, semi-keys & better dates
- Key dates / priority rarities
- No ordinary Bicentennial date is a key by date alone.
- Semi-keys / next checks
- No broadly recognized semi-key within a standard three-coin set.
- Better dates / collector issues
- High-grade, cameo and unusual varieties require specialist review.
- Varieties & identification
- 1976 dollar Type 1 / Type 2 applies to clad reverses; silver/clad identity comes before rarity claims.
1776–1976 on a coin does not itself make it rare or silver.
Series reference ↗Next step: No silver-based offer. Check exact set and approved buy list.
1968–1970 standard U.S. proof set
Only the Kennedy half contains silver: 40%. Other standard coins are base metal.
Key dates, semi-keys & better dates
- Key dates / priority rarities
- 1968 No-S dime PROOF; 1970 No-S dime PROOF—rare varieties, not every set.
- Semi-keys / next checks
- 1970-S Small Date cent variety.
- Better dates / collector issues
- Strong cameo / deep cameo coins and verified doubled dies.
- Varieties & identification
- Inspect the dime mintmark and exact cent variety without opening original packaging.
A normal Philadelphia circulation dime without a mintmark is not a No-S proof.
Series reference ↗Next step: Review completeness, condition and varieties before quote.
1971+ standard clad proof / mint sets
Standard clad sets have no silver; silver collector products are separate.
Key dates, semi-keys & better dates
- Key dates / priority rarities
- 1975 No-S dime PROOF; 1990 No-S cent PROOF; 1971 No-S nickel PROOF; 1983 No-S dime PROOF.
- Semi-keys / next checks
- 1979-S / 1981-S Type 2 proof mintmark varieties; 1996 mint set with W dime.
- Better dates / collector issues
- 1987 mint sets with collector-only halves; 1996 proof set can carry a set-market premium—use exact product bid.
- Varieties & identification
- No official regular uncirculated Mint Sets were sold for 1982 or 1983; souvenir sets are different products.
Do not transfer proof-set premiums to mint sets or vice versa. Confirm completeness and bonus coins.
Series reference ↗Next step: Use exact year and product; do not price by box color.
1992–2018 silver proof sets
Silver dime, quarter(s) and half are 90%; cent, nickel and regular small dollars are not silver.
Key dates, semi-keys & better dates
- Key dates / priority rarities
- No universal key coin-date list for all sets.
- Semi-keys / next checks
- 1999 silver proof set is a traditional set-market watch item.
- Better dates / collector issues
- 2012 silver proof set; 1995 and 1997 silver Premier sets are separate packaging products.
- Varieties & identification
- Check every silver denomination, quarter count and any missing or substituted pieces.
Set premiums fluctuate independently of silver content. Use a current exact-product bid; no premium is assumed.
Series reference ↗Next step: Add actual silver coins individually; verify year and completeness.
2019+ silver proof sets
Silver dime, quarter(s) and half are .999 silver; base-metal denominations remain separate.
Key dates, semi-keys & better dates
- Key dates / priority rarities
- No universal key-date hierarchy; verify the exact year and product.
- Semi-keys / next checks
- No blanket semi-key classification.
- Better dates / collector issues
- 2019 set with W reverse-proof cent; 2020 set with W reverse-proof nickel—verify the correct bonus piece is present.
- Varieties & identification
- Regular proof, silver proof, limited-edition silver proof and reverse-proof products are distinct.
A missing bonus coin can change completeness and resale bid. New-release low-mintage claims require current verification.
Series reference ↗Next step: Verify exact contents with Mint specifications; Clearwater for unfamiliar sets.
Other Items
Modern commemoratives
Identify exact denomination, year and composition; gold, silver and clad products exist.
Key dates, semi-keys & better dates
- Key dates / priority rarities
- Not applicable as one combined series.
- Semi-keys / next checks
- Not applicable as one combined series.
- Better dates / collector issues
- Issue, denomination, mintmark, finish and surviving demand determine desirability. No single key-date list applies across unrelated programs.
- Varieties & identification
- Send exact product photos and identifying marks to Clearwater.
Do not assume that an unlisted date or maker is common. All uncertain collector premiums require Clearwater review.
Series reference ↗Next step: Clearwater confirms issue, metal content and market bid.
Foreign coins / medals / plated collectibles
Identify country, denomination, date, weight and fineness from reliable references.
Key dates, semi-keys & better dates
- Key dates / priority rarities
- Not applicable as one combined series.
- Semi-keys / next checks
- Not applicable as one combined series.
- Better dates / collector issues
- Key dates depend on country, ruler, denomination and series. A universal year list would be misleading.
- Varieties & identification
- Send exact product photos and identifying marks to Clearwater.
Do not assume that an unlisted date or maker is common. All uncertain collector premiums require Clearwater review.
Series reference ↗Next step: Unknown metal, replica, plated, altered or unfamiliar item → Clearwater.
Certified / slabbed coins
Record grading service, certification number, grade and exact variety.
Key dates, semi-keys & better dates
- Key dates / priority rarities
- Not applicable as one combined series.
- Semi-keys / next checks
- Not applicable as one combined series.
- Better dates / collector issues
- Use the date list for the actual coin series. Certification service, grade, variety, holder and authenticity all need review.
- Varieties & identification
- Send exact product photos and identifying marks to Clearwater.
Do not assume that an unlisted date or maker is common. All uncertain collector premiums require Clearwater review.
Series reference ↗Next step: Clearwater reviews collector bid; never treat a printed price as the buy price.
When to call Clearwater
- Unknown coin, uncertain composition, mixed set or unfamiliar packaging.
- Key dates, errors, varieties, early U.S. coins, high grade, toned coins or unusual surfaces.
- Pre-1933 gold, foreign gold, collector premiums or any bid outside the approved schedule.
- Suspect authenticity, altered dates, counterfeit holders or conflicting test results.
Customer language: “Let me have our Clearwater coin specialist confirm the exact issue so we can give you an accurate offer.”
Send the expert what they need
- Clear front, back and edge photos; full date and mintmark.
- Weight in grams, diameter and non-destructive metal-test results.
- For sets: all coins, packaging and labels. For slabs: both sides and certification number.
- Quantity, condition concerns, customer asking price and store/buyer name.
Use IDC’s approved internal channel. No customer information is entered or transmitted by this page. Clearwater contact and purchase limits must come from management.
Counter rules that prevent expensive mistakes
Never clean coins. Do not scratch, acid-test or remove coins from holders without an approved procedure. Magnet, weight and edge checks are screening tools; passing one does not prove authenticity.
Keep 90%, 40%, 35% and .999 silver separate. For ordinary circulated 90% dimes, quarters and halves, the trade often uses approximately 0.715 fine troy oz per $1 face to allow for wear. Full-weight theoretical content is about 0.7234 oz. Neither factor applies to silver dollars, 40% halves, war nickels or modern .999 proofs. Heavily worn lots need review.
Melt is not the offer. Collector value can exceed melt; refining costs, market demand and resale risk affect bids. Use approved IDC pricing, not asking prices or a generic internet chart.